Musk: New York and California Took ID Off the Door — A Honest Voter Got Her Card Knocked Away/马斯克:纽约加州把门上的证件拿掉——守规矩的人把证件递上去,被当场打掉

64tianwang, Seattle, September 27, 2026 (volunteer editors)
【天网美西时间2026年9月27日 美国讯】(天网义工编辑)

(配图一:美国投票站外排队。门还没进,先要确认名册上的名字是不是本人。)

(Photo 1: A line outside a U.S. polling place. Before the door, the name on the book still has to be the person in line.)

At 12:04 p.m. Pacific Time on September 27, Elon Musk quoted his mother, Maye Musk, and wrote two lines. By afternoon the post showed about 1.6 million views.

美西9月27日下午12时04分,马斯克转发母亲梅耶·马斯克,只跟了两句。下午该帖显示约160万浏览。

“In New York and California, they have made it illegal for officials to ask for or for you to show your voter ID!
They made election fraud mandatory.”

中文:纽约和加州已经立法,官员不得索要选民证件,你出示也不行。等于把选举舞弊写成了必修课。

Maye’s post was shorter. She voted in New York. She showed ID. The woman at the table was angry and hit it away.

梅耶的原文更短:在纽约投票,出示证件,对面那个女人很生气,把证件打掉。

(配图二:马斯克转发母亲梅耶。原文:纽约加州官员不得索要、你出示选民证件也不行;等于把选举舞弊写成必修课。梅耶:在纽约投票出示证件,对方生气,把证件打掉。)
(Photo 2: Musk quoting Maye. He wrote that New York and California made it illegal for officials to ask for — or for a voter to show — voter ID; they made election fraud mandatory. Maye: in New York she showed ID; the woman was angry and hit it away.)

The statute is narrower than Musk’s two lines. New York and California do not, in most cases, require a photo ID at the poll. Poll-worker manuals say: if the roll does not mark “ID required,” do not ask. California in 2024 also barred local governments from adding their own ID rule. State offices have told reporters that a voter who volunteers an ID is not breaking the law. Some New York counties even let a driver license be scanned to find the name faster — they still may not make it a condition of voting.

法条比马斯克那两句窄。纽约、加州多数场合不要求投票时出示带照片的证件。工作人员手册写:名册没标 “ID required”,不要问。加州2024年还禁止地方自己加设查证。州选举办公室对媒体说过:选民自愿出示,并不违法。纽约有的县允许刷驾照加快找名,仍不能当成进门条件。

Write the three layers separately. The law took universal checks off the door. The manual told the clerk not to ask. The window then punished the person who still held out a card. A honest voter did extra work and was treated as a nuisance. The next person learns: put the card away. That is not a section titled “mandatory fraud.” It is a slope. On that slope, the person who wants to be identified is the one who gets hit.

三层要分开写。法把普遍查证从门口拿掉。手册叫窗口别问。窗口再把仍递证件的人训一顿。守规矩的人多走一步,换来的是找麻烦。下一个人就学会:证件收回去。这不是一部名叫“强制舞弊”的法。这是一条斜坡。斜坡上,愿意被核对的人先挨打。

The same weekend the Court, 6–3, gave states back SAVE — a tool to ask whether a name on the roll is a citizen. Musk that morning warned that legalizing 7 to 10 million people would lock a one-party state. This afternoon he points at the other hinge: if the door will not look at a card, the roll is only a list of signatures.

同一周末,最高法院6比3把 SAVE 还给各州——问名册上这人是不是公民。马斯克当天上午警告:一次把七百万到一千万人合法化,美国会变成一党国家。下午他指另一扇铰链:门口连证件都不看,名册就只剩签名。

About 40 minutes later, at 12:48 p.m. Pacific, commentator Eric Daugherty repeated Musk’s two lines and added three demands of his own: the Postal Service should stop sending mail ballots to states that will not check ID; no voter ID, no ballot; pass the SAVE America Act and lock the door on fraud. His clip showed California (54 House seats) and New York (28) in blue.

约40分钟后,美西下午12时48分,评论员埃里克·多尔蒂复述马斯克那两句,自己又加了三句:邮政总局不该再向不查证件的州寄邮寄选票;没有选民证件,就不该拿到票;通过 SAVE America Act,把舞弊的门闩上。片子上,加州(众议院54席)和纽约(28席)涂成蓝色。

Two different “SAVE.” The system in last week’s Court order is DHS SAVE: it asks whether a name on the roll is a citizen. The SAVE America Act (Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act) is a House bill: proof of citizenship to register, photo ID to vote. President Trump has also asked that no-excuse mail ballots be cut to a few exceptions. The House passed it 218–213 in February 2026. The Senate has not. Daugherty’s call to halt USPS ballots is a slogan, not a standing federal order. Elections are run by the states.

两个“SAVE”不要混。上周最高法院那道令里的,是国土安全部的 SAVE 系统:问名册上这人是不是公民。SAVE America Act(保卫美国选民资格法)是众议院法案:登记要公民身份文件,投票要带照片的证件。川普总统还要求把无理由邮寄投票收到少数例外。众议院2026年2月以218比213过了。参议院还没有。多尔蒂要邮政停寄,是主张,不是已经生效的联邦命令。选举由州来办。

64tianwang comment:
六四天网认为:

A country that buys liquor with an ID and boards a plane with an ID, but treats a voter ID as an insult, has decided which act it thinks is serious.

出示驾照才能买酒、登机,出示选民证件却像冒犯,说明这个地方已经选定:哪一件事不必认真。

Maye did what an adult citizen should do. She proved who she was. The window knocked the proof away. Encourage that once, and honest people stop offering proof. People who do not want to be known keep walking in. You do not need a statute called “mandatory fraud.” You only need a door that punishes the ones who tell the truth.

梅耶做了成年公民该做的事。她证明自己是谁。窗口把证明打掉。鼓励一次,诚实的人就不再递。不愿被认出的人继续往里走。不必单独立一部“强制舞弊法”。只要门口专打说实话的人,就够了。

Musk named the door. Daugherty named the mailbox. One system checks the roll. One bill would check the person. Until both exist, a card can still be knocked away, and a ballot can still arrive with no face attached.

马斯克点的是门口。多尔蒂点的是邮箱。一套系统核名册。一部法案核人。两样都还没齐,证件仍可以被打掉,选票仍可以不附脸寄到。

November 3 is not only a date. It is whether the name on the book can still be checked.

11月3日不只是一个日子。它问的是:名册上的名字,还能不能被核对。

(End)
(完)

(64tianwang, based on Elon Musk’s X post, 12:04 p.m. Pacific, Sept. 27, 2026, quoting Maye Musk; New York and California poll-worker guidance)
(六四天网 综合马斯克X平台美西2026年9月27日下午12时04分帖文及梅耶·马斯克陈述,并对照纽约、加州投票站工作指导)

Related
天网相关链接:
https://64tianwang.net/archives/4614
https://64tianwang.net/archives/4617